Fight Club - 10th Anniversary

its a decent movie but what about the huge plot hole that this guy is one person with schizophrenia but somehow he manages to be in 2 places throughout pretty much the whole movie, and he is talking to his imaginary friend and his friends are talking to his imaginary friend but none of them ask him wtf is going on or say anything about it at all...

  On 11/29/2009 at 12:31 PM, MAXIMUS MISCHIEF said:

its a decent movie but what about the huge plot hole that this guy is one person with schizophrenia but somehow he manages to be in 2 places throughout pretty much the whole movie, and he is talking to his imaginary friend and his friends are talking to his imaginary friend but none of them ask him wtf is going on or say anything about it at all...

You don't actually see Tyler talking to "Jack" when anyone is around. You only see them hug at one point (after they've painted the smiley face on the building) and "Jack" says something like: "Hey, what's going on?" and there's another scene where Tyler is being beat up by the bar owner (Lou) and Jack is just about to help him when Tyler tells him and a bunch of other guys to stop.

  On 11/29/2009 at 12:31 PM, MAXIMUS MISCHIEF said:

its a decent movie but what about the huge plot hole that this guy is one person with schizophrenia but somehow he manages to be in 2 places throughout pretty much the whole movie, and he is talking to his imaginary friend and his friends are talking to his imaginary friend but none of them ask him wtf is going on or say anything about it at all...

I think the conversations which Norton's character has with Tyler was all in his mind

By the way, people are saying it's a shit film in this thread, but they're not stating their reasons why, so go ahead and say why it's not a good film.