Finally! Lucas Gets Something Right

  On 9/20/2011 at 2:57 PM, Coalbucket PI said:

I need to get the original trilogy on DVD, is it still possible to get the original versions? Or what is the best box set?

http://www.play.com/DVD/DVD/4-/1011234/Star-Wars-Episode-IV-A-New-Hope/Product.html?searchtype=r2alldvd&searchsource=0&searchstring=star+wars&urlrefer=search&strefer=r2alldvd&searchfilters=s{star+wars}%2bc{57}%2b

what a fucking apologist

  Quote

No, the "untouched" original trilogy is not included. Yes, there are some goofy new additions, like Darth Vader yelling "NOOOOO" as he throws Emperor Palpatine over the railing. I don't think anyone expected this release ofThe Complete Saga to be free of controversy. But come on. It's Star Wars. On Blu-ray. This is a once-in-a-technological-generation event, and if your hatred of George Lucas' revisionist tinkerings keeps you from enjoying some of your favorite films in high definition, you're missing out. Believe me, I share your pain. Whenever I hear that stupid funk song inside Jabba's palace, I cringe like a man being forced to bite down on tin foil or chew sand. It's almost physically painful. But I'm done being bitter. I'm playing the long game. One of these days, Lucas will wise up and realize that the original trilogy—in its original form—is a culturally and historically important piece of pop art that belongs to its fans. But until that day, I'm going to enjoy this Blu-ray box set. The films have never looked or sounded better— Episodes III-VI are particularly impressive—and they come with a fantastic collection of special features. Highly Recommended!

  On 9/20/2011 at 6:48 PM, oscillik said:

what a fucking apologist

 

  Quote

No, the "untouched" original trilogy is not included. Yes, there are some goofy new additions, like Darth Vader yelling "NOOOOO" as he throws Emperor Palpatine over the railing. I don't think anyone expected this release ofThe Complete Saga to be free of controversy. But come on. It's Star Wars. On Blu-ray. This is a once-in-a-technological-generation event, and if your hatred of George Lucas' revisionist tinkerings keeps you from enjoying some of your favorite films in high definition, you're missing out. Believe me, I share your pain. Whenever I hear that stupid funk song inside Jabba's palace, I cringe like a man being forced to bite down on tin foil or chew sand. It's almost physically painful. But I'm done being bitter. I'm playing the long game. One of these days, Lucas will wise up and realize that the original trilogy—in its original form—is a culturally and historically important piece of pop art that belongs to its fans. But until that day, I'm going to enjoy this Blu-ray box set. The films have never looked or sounded better— Episodes III-VI are particularly impressive—and they come with a fantastic collection of special features. Highly Recommended!

Sounds like while he, like many of us dislike what Lucas has done to his movies, he can still find enjoyment in them. I see nothing apologetic about that.

how the balls could a person highly recommend something that they state is "almost physically painful?" unless you're into that kind of thing

i'm with underscore on this.

  On 9/20/2011 at 8:04 PM, underscore said:

how the balls could a person highly recommend something that they state is "almost physically painful?" unless you're into that kind of thing

RTFQA: He said he found the Jabba's Palace Musical Number and it's music "almost physically painful", not the vast majority of the rest of the film (or the other films for that matter).

you think I didn't realize that quote was taken out of context? it still doesn't change the fact that the guys positive review is basically based on ONE statement he makes in the entire thing; "But come on. It's Star Wars. On Blu-ray". when half a review is NEGATIVE, I do not expect the product to be "highly recommended."

  On 9/20/2011 at 8:29 PM, underscore said:

you think I didn't realize that quote was taken out of context? it still doesn't change the fact that the guys positive review is basically based on ONE statement he makes in the entire thing; "But come on. It's Star Wars. On Blu-ray". when half a review is NEGATIVE, I do not expect the product to be "highly recommended."

exactly why i called him a "fucking apologist"

  Quote

...like Darth Vader yelling "NOOOOO" as he throws Emperor Palpatine over the railing.

And here I was thinking that was just a youtube joke and not official He totally lost it.

  On 9/20/2011 at 8:55 PM, vasio said:

  Quote

...like Darth Vader yelling "NOOOOO" as he throws Emperor Palpatine over the railing.

 

And here I was thinking that was just a youtube joke and not official He totally lost it.

i guess you didn't read through the rest of this thread where it's already been confirmed that it is for real

  On 9/20/2011 at 8:29 PM, underscore said:

you think I didn't realize that quote was taken out of context? it still doesn't change the fact that the guys positive review is basically based on ONE statement he makes in the entire thing; "But come on. It's Star Wars. On Blu-ray". when half a review is NEGATIVE, I do not expect the product to be "highly recommended."

I guess I need to draw you a picture (of sorts):

red = negative

green = positive

No, the "untouched" original trilogy is not included. Yes, there are some goofy new additions, like Darth Vader yelling "NOOOOO" as he throws Emperor Palpatine over the railing. I don't think anyone expected this release of The Complete Saga to be free of controversy. But come on. It's Star Wars. On Blu-ray. This is a once-in-a-technological-generation event, and if your hatred of George Lucas' revisionist tinkerings keeps you from enjoying some of your favorite films in high definition, you're missing out. Believe me, I share your pain. Whenever I hear that stupid funk song inside Jabba's palace, I cringe like a man being forced to bite down on tin foil or chew sand. It's almost physically painful. But I'm done being bitter. I'm playing the long game. One of these days, Lucas will wise up and realize that the original trilogy—in its original form—is a culturally and historically important piece of pop art that belongs to its fans. But until that day, I'm going to enjoy this Blu-ray box set. The films have never looked or sounded better— Episodes III-VI are particularly impressive—and they come with a fantastic collection of special features. Highly Recommended!

At best, I see the "review" (was this really the whole review?) as positive, with some noted negatives. I also disagree about it belonging to the fans bit - it's Lucas' movies, and he can do whatever he wants to them.

Also, you can look at his negative statements to be personal opinion, and not an actual reflection of the quality of the product, as some people may enjoy (or at best be oblivious to) the changes Lucas has made.

Thanks Pee and Squigster

  On 9/20/2011 at 8:03 PM, Joyrex said:

  On 9/20/2011 at 6:48 PM, oscillik said:

what a fucking apologist

 

  Quote

No, the "untouched" original trilogy is not included. Yes, there are some goofy new additions, like Darth Vader yelling "NOOOOO" as he throws Emperor Palpatine over the railing. I don't think anyone expected this release ofThe Complete Saga to be free of controversy. But come on. It's Star Wars. On Blu-ray. This is a once-in-a-technological-generation event, and if your hatred of George Lucas' revisionist tinkerings keeps you from enjoying some of your favorite films in high definition, you're missing out. Believe me, I share your pain. Whenever I hear that stupid funk song inside Jabba's palace, I cringe like a man being forced to bite down on tin foil or chew sand. It's almost physically painful. But I'm done being bitter. I'm playing the long game. One of these days, Lucas will wise up and realize that the original trilogy—in its original form—is a culturally and historically important piece of pop art that belongs to its fans. But until that day, I'm going to enjoy this Blu-ray box set. The films have never looked or sounded better— Episodes III-VI are particularly impressive—and they come with a fantastic collection of special features. Highly Recommended!

 

Sounds like while he, like many of us dislike what Lucas has done to his movies, he can still find enjoyment in them. I see nothing apologetic about that.

having watched a new hope on blu-ray, i can agree 100% with this guys reviews.

the additions are horrible, but it's still absolutely amazing seeing the films in this new restored condition.

funny how some people seem to enjoy being violated.

also I would have loved to have been a fly on the wall when Lucas asked the guy to insert the "nooo" into the Vader scene - must have been quite a reaction

^Maybe GL found out about Audacity & did it himself.

Next year he's gonna find out about Fruity Loops & redo the entire soundtrack WITH BEATS

Torrent the original untoched ones, get your fix with new stuff each 5 years. Not bad. Now only if they were anamorphic.